top of page

North Yorkshire Climate Coalition

​

​Response to the Mayor’s Draft Local Transport Plan 
 

The Steering Group of North Yorkshire Climate Coalition wishes to submit the following points in response to the consultation on the Mayor’s draft Local Transport Plan (LTP).

 

Endorsement

Firstly, we wish to endorse the joint community response already submitted – with input from multiple groups in the region, including North Yorkshire Climate Coalition – by the organisation Low Traffic Future [1].

The above joint response broadly welcomes the ambitions of the Mayor’s draft Local Transport Plan (LTP), as set out in the 4 ‘strands’ of the Vision, the 5 ‘priorities for change’ and the 6 ‘network principles’. However, it also highlights a number of areas in which the draft plan could be improved, e.g. through the inclusion of a quantifiable carbon assessment, assessments of environmental impacts (notably on air quality), detailed metrics, funding plans and spending priorities.

In addition to the points raised in the above joint response, North Yorkshire Climate Coalition wishes to make the following observations focused more closely on the potential of the LTP to contribute to climate aspects of the Mayor’s Strategy for a Sustainable Future York and North Yorkshire.

 

Additional climate-focused comments

We strongly support the vision of delivering a decarbonised transport system that will help make York and North Yorkshire carbon negative by 2040.

However, while the vision is welcome, the climate emergency requires more than aspirations. As Prof. Greg Marsden's research on transport decarbonisation warns, road travel is currently falling dangerously behind on the cuts needed to avoid blowing past our safe carbon limits [2]. As it stands, in relation to climate policy, too much of the draft LTP relies on vague ambitions. As a general observation, we would like to see more concrete measures explicitly designed to achieve specific goals in terms of cleaner air, the natural environment and our net-zero/carbon-negative targets. This will require a clearer picture of funding priorities, carbon targets and other environmental benefits. 

Accordingly, focusing on environmental and climate aspects of the plan, we suggest the following potential improvements to the existing draft.

 

Carbon mitigation (aligned with the Sustainable Future YNY Strategy)

  • Clear pathways and interim targets: In line with the Government’s Quantifiable Carbon Guidance, we would like to see a much clearer picture of the carbon savings achievable under the proposed LTP, with a defined pathway that sets out baseline figures, interim and final targets (in % and absolute figures), oversight arrangements, review mechanisms, proposed incentives and disincentives, and consistent cross-referencing to the Sustainable Future YNY strategy.

  • The ‘area under the curve’ principle: Targets should be set with due regard for the ‘area under the curve’ principle. As highlighted by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), cumulative emissions dictate overall climate warming [3]. To maximise the overall climate mitigation impact and conversely minimise future cumulative emissions, all measures should be designed to start working as early as possible (i.e. avoiding implementation delays) and aim for an ambitious but steady pace of reduction rather than back-loading the reduction towards the end of the target period.

  • A bold approach to demand reduction: As noted in the LTF joint response (see above), we welcome the inclusion of a target to reduce the proportion of trips made by private motor vehicles, from 62% at present to 50% in 2050. However, in the absence of a quantifiable carbon assessment, it is not clear that this target is sufficient to achieve the carbon negative ambition of the Sustainable Future YNY strategy. Research from Green Alliance demonstrates that even with optimistic assumptions regarding the uptake of electric vehicles (EVs), transport requires at least a 20% reduction in car-kilometres by 2030 to stay within carbon budgets [4]. To make this happen, the LTP will need to include bold, appropriate and effective incentives and disincentives.

  • Incentives for low-carbon travel: Incentivising low-carbon public transport requires a mix of financial, structural and behavioural mechanisms to drive a modal shift away from private cars, e.g. fare capping, scrappage schemes, PR campaigns that promote ‘usership’ rather than ‘ownership’. As detailed in the ClimateWorks Foundation research (How travel rewards can incentivize low-carbon transportation), targeted positive reinforcement can effectively alter travel habits [5]. Furthermore, supporting active travel infrastructure is essential. This includes walking, wheeling and cycling, which must become the natural choice for short journeys, backed by default 20mph limits in busy areas and better everyday maintenance of footways and cycleways.

  • Disincentivising high-carbon choices: Importantly, as well as incentivising the use of low-carbon options, the plan should consider ways of disincentivising high-carbon choices, e.g. through higher parking charges for oversized vehicles (‘car-spreading') [6], congestion pricing and workplace parking levies (following successful models like Nottingham's or international precedents in Paris and Cardiff) [7, 8, 9]. While politically challenging, disincentivisation succeeds when paired with transparent messaging that emphasises fairness, public health cost co-benefits, and the right of non-drivers to breathe clean air [10, 11].

 

Active travel, health co-benefits and evidence-based safety

  • Making active travel safe and attractive: Walking, wheeling and cycling must be genuinely safe, attractive and accessible for everyday trips, spanning links between villages and school runs, not just town centres. We would like the LTP to emphasise the benefits of lower speed limits (default 20mph in busy areas and safer limits on narrow rural lanes) and attractive, well-maintained pathways so that active travel is the most scenic and highly visible option for residents and visitors.

  • Health and economic co-benefits: Transport emissions drive chronic health problems, such as obesity, type 2 diabetes, cardiovascular disease and respiratory illness [12, 13]. We would like to see a greater emphasis in the LTP on the co-benefits of a shift towards active travel. Interventions in this area can generate significant and measurable improvements in physical and mental health, reduce strain on the NHS and emergency services, revitalise high streets and promote local economic resilience [12, 13].

  • Supporting real behaviour change: The LTP should include measures to ensure that new walking and cycling routes are backed by local, community-led programmes. These can include cycle training for all ages and abilities, school travel initiatives and local bike-share schemes so people have the confidence and support to leave the car at home.

​

Rural integration and the benefits of rural connectivity

  • Addressing rural isolation and fuel poverty: In a large, sparsely populated county such as North Yorkshire, rural areas deserve to be considered from the beginning. The LTP should afford greater priority to measures that address car dependency, rural fuel poverty and the issue of isolation among the young, the elderly and residents who do not have access to a private vehicle.

  • The ‘Every Village Every Hour’ standard: We urge the Combined Authority to commit to robust service benchmarks, such as the Swiss-inspired standard highlighted in CPRE's Every Village Every Hour report (delivering at least an hourly bus service throughout the day, 7 days a week, for settlements with populations of 300 or more) [14].

  • Co-benefits of integration: We strongly support the ambition to deliver an integrated local transport system that extends to rural communities. True rural integration would unlock massive economic and social co-benefits. Examples of this are by combining fixed-route bus services, demand-responsive transport (DRT) pilots and rural rail links (such as supporting the Skipton-to-Colne rail line restoration and Whitby-to-Malton enhancements). This approach reduces carbon emissions while protecting high streets and market towns from unattractive traffic congestion and poor air quality.

 

Joining up transport with housing and planning

We support the ambition to link transport with land-use planning, especially as the Combined Authority takes on strategic planning powers.

However, right now, the draft LTP and the emerging North Yorkshire Local Plan feel disconnected. Sustainable transport cannot be effectively and strategically planned without knowing where new homes will be built, as new housing risks locking residents into greater car dependency. Buses, trains and cycle paths should be in place before the first residents move in. We urge the Combined Authority and North Yorkshire Council to work together to ensure new developments are built around sustainable transport from day one.

​

Conclusion

The York and North Yorkshire region has the capacity to be a true climate steward for the UK. By backing up this draft vision with clear spending plans, joined-up land-use policies and measurable carbon targets, the Mayor can deliver a transport network that works for our climate, our local economy and every community across the region. 

​

Sources

  1. Low Traffic Future Alliance (2026): Joint Response for York and North Yorkshire Groups – Local Transport Plan Consultation. Available at: https://lowtrafficfuture.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/2611_RG-for-YNY-groups_LTP-joint-response_con.pdf

  2. Marsden, G. (University of Leeds / IN-FUZE): Transport Decarbonisation & Overshoot Report. Available at: https://in-fuze.org.uk/overshoot-report/

  3. IPCC (2021): AR6 Working Group I Summary for Policymakers – Figure SPM.10 (Cumulative CO2 Emissions). Available at: https://www.ipcc.ch/report/ar6/wg1/figures/summary-for-policymakers/figure-spm-10

  4. Green Alliance (2021): Not Going the Extra Mile: Driving Less to Tackle Climate Change. Available at: https://green-alliance.org.uk/publication/not-going-the-extra-mile/

  5. ClimateWorks Foundation: How Travel Rewards Can Incentivize Low-Carbon Transportation. Available at: https://www.climateworks.org/blog/how-travel-rewards-can-incentivize-low-carbon-transportation/

  6. Clean Cities Campaign (2026): Carspreading in the UK: Key Facts. Available at: https://cleancitiescampaign.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/Carspreading-Key-Facts-2026-5.pdf

  7. Transport Action Network (2023): Case Study: Nottingham Workplace Parking Levy. Available at: https://transportactionnetwork.org.uk/nottingham-workplace-parking-levy/

  8. European Commission Urban Mobility Observatory (2024): Paris introduces triple parking fees for SUVs. Available at: https://urban-mobility-observatory.transport.ec.europa.eu/news-events/news/paris-introduces-triple-parking-fees-suvs-2024-02-12_en

  9. Cardiff Council: Summary of Charging Options We Considered (Workplace Parking Levy & Road-User Charging). Available at: https://www.cardiff.gov.uk/article/6027/Summary-of-charging-options-we-considered

  10. Local Government Association (2024): Strategies for local traffic demand management: A discussion paper. Available at: https://www.local.gov.uk/publications/strategies-local-traffic-demand-management-discussion-paper

  11. Rashid, R. et al. / BMC Public Health (2021): Taking a deep breath: a qualitative study exploring acceptability and perceived unintended consequences of charging clean air zones and air quality improvement initiatives. Available at: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8255006/

  12. Department for Transport / Active Travel England (2026): The Health and Wellbeing Impacts of Active Travel. Available at: https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/697b3fb6043a4ade0f7b4fa7/active-travel-health-wellbeing-impacts-active-travel.pdf

  13. Public Health England / GOV.UK (2020): Health matters: physical activity – prevention and management of long-term conditions. Available at: https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/health-matters-physical-activity/health-matters-physical-activity-prevention-and-management-of-long-term-conditions

  14. CPRE, the countryside charity (2021): Every Village, Every Hour: A Comprehensive Bus Network for Rural England. Available at: Every village, every hour 2021 buses report: full report - CPRE

​

18 November 2026

North Yorkshire Climate Coalition

bottom of page